Psychological Reasons For Overspending & How To Outsmart Them (Spoiler Alert: It’s Not YOUR Fault!)

Wanna know the psychological reasons for overspending and why it has NOTHING to do with you being ‘bad with money’? Buckle up, because this post is dedicated to dismantling everything you’ve been told about your spending habits. If you’ve ever felt ashamed for ‘not having enough character & self-control’, then I’m here to defend & have your back: because the problem isn’t you.

We’ve all been there, right? You promise yourself you’d ‘be better’ this month, only to end up stress-buying things you don’t really need. When you look at your bank statement and feel despair that you’ve failed again? Yeah, we overachievers instantly jump on the negative-self talk bandwagon and trash-talk the shit out of ourselves.

What you’re going to learn is why overspending has nothing to do with a lack of character, discipline, or self-control, but is a psychological and environmental response to your circumstances. You’ll discover how stress and survival mode make ‘smart financial choices’ almost impossible. And! How companies profit from that exact vulnerability. Most importantly, you’ll learn how to start taking back responsibility & control without the freakin’ scapegoating shame spiral.

After you’ve learned to identify the triggers and needs underneath your spending habits, you’ll be able to start breaking free from the guilt cycle. You’ll understand why financial struggles aren’t about ‘knowing better’ (because DUH, we all KNOW not to spend more than we earn), and learn how to start outsmarting the forces pushing you to overspend. You’ll feel more in control and finally, FINALLY, will be able to ditch the ‘bad with money’ label that was never yours to begin with.

This post is all about the psychological reasons for overspending so you can stop blaming yourself and break free from the terrible system trapping you in survival mode & subconscious spending struggles.

---

Psychological Reasons For Overspending

You know what’s wild? The world will shame you for overspending & impulse buying in a heartbeat, yes!? As soon as money problems arrive, you’re kinda treated like a child. How dare you, you bad human! Their subtext says. When you mess up, you “need to question your actions (true), self-worth, character, discipline, and self-control” (not true). But, at the same time, the bigger societal system is making damn sure you stay stuck, functioning as the perfect customer. So freakin’ dirty!

Everywhere you go, it’s that waving catholic-guilt-finger with ‘You should know & do better, you sinner!’, focusing on blaming you for DROWNING. But nobody ever provided ‘swimming lessons’ and everyone is just thrown into the deep. Ever had one personal finance class in your life? There’s no such thing, right!? No budgeting 101, no ‘here’s how to actually stay in charge of what you’ve earned’. Just, sink or swim, and when you drown, you’re WEAK.

This system is designed to set you up for failure. What they really need is for you to identify with ‘I’m just bad with money’, so they can profit from your financial denial. But, believe me, you have way more power than you realize. And they don’t want you to own that.

RELATED POST:
How To Pull Yourself Out Of Financial Denial: An Overachiever’s Strategy To Get Back In Control

Why You’re Not A Failure, But A Victim Of An Immoral Exploitative System

Unfortunately. We’re expected to figure money management out ‘by trial and error’. But! Every mistake will be shamed and cost actual money. And more than actual money! It’s actually costing you your mental health when you’re attacked on your character! Because it’s an extremely painful experience to be treated that pejoratively by society & people you care about.

This whole system is designed to profit off your guilt, shame, and ‘not knowing’ how to stay in control. They drown you in sharp algorithm-targeted ads, make debt look ‘normal’, and gamify spending like it’s a damn casino. And when you finally reach that inevitable rock bottom and struggle? Yeah, they’ll roll their eyes, look down on you and call it ‘lack of discipline’.

The hypocrisy is absolutely mind-blowing. It’s NOT about what’s wrong with you. It’s about how well this system is designed to keep you trapped. The more you’re stuck chasing dopamine highs, the richer they can get over your back. Convenient to push you into self-blame right? Seriously? This isn’t a character flaw. It’s a rigged game. And you deserve to be pissed about it.

POVERTY ISN’T A LACK OF CHARACTER, BUT A LACK OF CASH

UK Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher was the poster girl for this toxic shame dynamic, and actually claimed that poverty was a ‘personality defect’. Let that sink in! A whole generation in Western civilization was raised with the belief that if you’re broke, it’s your OWN fault for failing!? Certainly not business & the economy, right? Not the systemic financial traps. Nahhhh. Just YOU. And unfortunately, that blaming mindset is still embedded in how society treats financial struggles today.

Rutger Bregman called this out in his grand, idealistic & controversial TED-Talk: ‘Poverty isn’t a lack of character; it’s a lack of cash’. If you have a couple of minutes, I highly recommend watching this. He argues that poverty isn’t about intelligence, laziness, or ‘bad decision-making’. In fact. The last is a SYMPTOM of poverty & scarcity mentality.

It’s really about being trapped in constant survival mode! And science shows, when you’re in survival mode, you’re prefrontal cortex isn’t even ‘online’. Ever seen a brain scan of a stressed person in survival mode? Yeah. That thinking part of our brain is actually turned OFF. Off, as in, it doesn’t even light up! So, yeah, duh, of course, you don’t think clearly & aren’t really able to make the right decisions. That’s not a character flaw, that’s brutal.

George Orwell is also mentioned with a quote in Bregman’s talk: ‘Poverty annihilates the future’. Aka. You can’t think long-term when all alarm bells are screaming at you ‘How do I get through this week/month!’. Instead of fixing the root cause, we offer symptom treatments, blame & shame. No wonder there’s no real change. And who profits from this again? I hope you start to get it.

Why The Real Problem Is A Lack Of Control, Not Lack Of Character

So I beg off you. Can we just get rid of this shaming opinion once and for all? You don’t overspend & impulse buy because you don’t KNOW better. This is such a dirty blame dynamic. We ALL know the basic rule: don’t spend more than you earn. It’s not about knowledge! It’s about needing to learn the SKILLS & STRATEGIES to stay in control against big business that’s the real problem! Knowledge means nothing without owning & applying it, and marketing is built to take every tiny bit of control away from you.

That financial denial is not a lack of discipline! Hell no! That’s big business WINNING the game. Because if you don’t have a plan, they’ll make damn sure they have one FOR YOU. And you can guess it, right? Their plan ends with you broke and them richer. Think about it. Big corporations count on your overspending. They study it. They use it. They market it so seamlessly that you don’t even realize it’s happening! And then, when you’re wondering where your paycheck went, the only ‘solution’ they offer is another payment. Neat.

What’s your next move? You know you have to take that power back, right? Let’s dive into some counterattacks!

Owning a cashflow strategy is a skill that’ll give you some serious advantages in life. I think budgeting is an aligned action with taking life seriously, and I seriously believe life will reward you for it. If you’re not into high-maintenance strategies like ‘tracking your spending’ and just want to sit down ONCE to direct your financial future, our Guilt-Free Spending Plan Printable is the right cashflow strategy for you! Don’t let anybody outsmart you out of your own money and start budgeting today by simply filling out the form below:

The Psychological Reason: Finding The Underlying Need For Overspending

When you’re overspending, it’s never really about the money. It’s about the feeling & experience that you’re chasing. This is very important to realize. You NEED & DESIRE to give your family a warm feeling and therefore overspend on meals or outings. You NEED & DESIRE to feel socially safe by looking good and therefore you shop too much. So this is your emotional homework for today. Ask yourself what is the benefit of the benefit that you’re getting, BECAUSE: If you can identify your real need underneath the spending behavior, you can meet that need in other ways that are less ‘at the cost of you’.

Be bluntly honest with yourself here. Nobody has to know that it’s about trying to prove yourself to your parents. Or to society. Maybe you fall for keeping up with those damn Joneses or feel insecure and overcompensate for it. Your spending habits tell a story about you, and for now, you need to find out that subtext on your own. Trust me, the marketing techniques are also trying to figure you out (to use it against you, duh). So! Until you know yourself, your desires & your needs, you’ll keep treating a symptom (overspending) instead of the root cause (fulfilling your actual needs & desires).

This is where Dr. Carol Yip’s TED Talk comes in. She breaks down how spending is rarely about numbers. It’s about emotions, perception, and mostly unmet needs. This is why it’s so important to get to know yourself & your desires. If you don’t get to the root of why you spend, you’ll always be fighting an uphill battle. The key isn’t knowing what to stop buying. It’s understanding what you’re really trying to gain emotionally.

Ending The Overidentification With ‘Being Bad With Money’: Take Your Power Back

Now let’s take the last real step towards breaking up with financial struggles, shall we? You are NOT ‘bad with money’. This is a label that targets you as ‘easy PREY’. Ditch that label. I’m dead serious. The more you’re convinced that you can’t change, the easier you are to manipulate. But you’re reading this far because you WANT to change. And you have way more power than you give yourself credit for.

So how do you break out? When you’re in survival mode, you NEED dopamine hits to make life less hard. But you can find less harmful dopamine to ‘treat yourself’ with. Which one is of course to you. Dopamine will always have the ‘not good label’, but when you’re in survival mode, you only need to focus on finding dopamine hits that are less impactful and detrimental than the one you are using now.

Next, ditch that ‘bad with money’ identity. The moment you stop saying you’re a financial disaster, you take away THEIR power of you. And how do you make that reality? GET A STRATEGY. Not a vague ‘spend less’ plan. No. An actual cashflow strategy that keeps you in control, not big business. Here, intentional spending is going to be your best friend. It’s not about punishment & restriction. It’s about gaining choice. You start to walk a path of life where spending is on your terms, aligned with your goals, needs & desires.

RELATED POST:
Intentional Spending: The CEO-Mindset And AntiDote Against Overspending & Impulse Buying

Stop being an easy target. Get a system. Get a grip. And take that damn power back!

Psychological Reasons For Overspending (Summary)

Overspending is NOT a personal failure. It’s a psychological & environmental response to a system designed to keep you consuming. Society loves to shame people for money struggles, pushing the myth that financial problems are due to ‘lack of discipline’. But as Rutger Bregman’s Ted Talk exposes, poverty & financial stress hijack your brain, trapping you in survival mode where long-term decision-making isn’t even biologically an option.

Big business profits off your financial denial, keeping you stuck in overspending, overwhelmed, and easy to manipulate with target marketing. The real power move? Ditching that ‘bad with money’ identity and taking control with goal setting, cashflow strategies & intentional spending so you’re back in the driver’s seat. This isn’t about neurotically budgeting harder. It’s about outsmarting a system that profits off keeping you broke with strategy.

I hope you’ll consider actually owning your money. You deserve to be in charge of it. I don’t mean that the fluff way, you actually EARNED that money. It SHOULD be yours to own! So I encourage you to stop being the perfect customer and start being the CEO of your financial life.

This post was all about the psychological reasons for overspending so you can stop blaming yourself and break free from the terrible system trapping you in survival mode & subconscious spending struggles.

We aim to help you out as much as possible, but please keep in mind that the content is for general informational and educational purposes only. It's not a substitute for professional advice.